IN-STORE MENU

all items available january 8th - february 28th

Title

sweet pies

prices are listed as whole/slice

Apple Crumble Pie

36.50 / 7.00

Our apple crumble pie was the first ever to come out of the Pots & Pans oven, and it’s been on the menu ever since! Apples sweetened and spiced just right, topped with a buttery-sweet brown sugar crumble. Made from scratch with our signature lard-and-butter crust.

Sugar Creme Brulee Pie

34.50 / 6.50

Our take on the Hoosier Pie! We brulee the top, giving it a crisp texture and a toasty caramel flavor. Winner of “The Talk” Food Face-off on CBS. Made from scratch with our signature lard-and-butter crust.

Banana Cream Pie 

39.50 / 7.25

 vegetarian 

Bananas, pastry cream, caramel, and chocolate. What’s not to love? Made from scratch with our vegetarian butter-and-egg crust.

Bruce's Lemon Pie 

36.50 / 7.00

A traditional lemon pie made with a graham crust and topped with whipped cream. Made from scratch with a graham cracker crust.

*Contains Gelatin*  

Chocolate Tahini Chess Pie

34.50 / 6.50

This decadent, brownie-like chess pie is made with tahini (sesame butter) to give it a rich, toasty flavor.  Made from scratch with our signature flaky lard-and-butter crust.

Turtle IceBox Pie 

39.59 / 7.25

 vegetarian 

This traditional icebox pie is served frozen, but it's soft and creamy straight out of the freezer. Features a caramel and butter pecan filling with chocolate crust and drizzle. Made from scratch with our Oreo pie crust. Keep frozen, eat frozen!
Title

take & bake pot pies

prices are listed as 6"/9"

6" pot pies feed 1-2     9" pot pies feed 4-6

BBQ Mac & Cheese Pot Pie 

15.50 / 40.50

 seasonal 

Our BBQ pork pot pie is here for cozy season! Filled with hickory-smoked pulled pork from Indiana's finest, Half Liter BBQ – plus our sorta-famous macaroni & cheese. We won't stop there! Hot out of the oven, pour a generous helping of Half Liter BBQ's sweet and tangy Cola BBQ Sauce to seal the deal. Made from scratch with our signature flaky lard-and-butter crust.

Beef & Mushroom Pot Pie

15.50 / 40.50

braised beef • crimini • red wine • bacon • leeks

Classic Chicken Pot Pie

13.50 / 36.50

chicken • carrots • cream • mushrooms • peas • red potatoes

Broccoli Cheddar Pot Pie

13.50 / 36.50

 vegetarian 

new york cheddar • parmesan • broccoli • carrots • red potatoes

Chicken Masala Pot Pie

14.50 / 39.50

chicken • golden raisins • apples • cilantro • house garam masala

Biscuits & Gravy Pot Pie

13.50 / 36.50

pork sausage gravy • bacon • onions • black pepper

Green Chile Pork Pot Pie

15.50 / 40.50

pork shoulder • hatch chiles • tomatillo • sweet potatoes • sweet corn • cumin

Macaroni & Cheese

7.50 / 14.50

 vegetarian 

giant macaroni • new york cheddar • velveeta • cream cheese • panko
Title

pastries & cookies

Apple Cream Cheese   Galette 

6.00

Flaky pastry filled with sweet cream cheese and tart Granny smith apples. Finished with sugar and cinnamon, topped with crunchy almonds slicies. 

Oatmeal Cream Pie

5.00

 vegetarian 

Oatmeal cookie, swiss meringue buttercream

*Vegetarian*

Shortbread Chocolate Chip Cookie 

2.50 

 vegetarian 

Buttery, melt-in-your-mouth shortbread loaded with rich chocolate chips.

*Vegetarian*

Creamy French Onion Handpie

6.00

 vegetarian 

Caramelized onions, cream cheese, and tamari

*Vegetarian*

Country Ham & Beer Cheese Handpie 

6.00

Prosciutto, lager beer, cheddar cheese, and cream cheese