Yes we can, because we now ship nationwide on Goldbelly!

If you live in central Indiana but want to save a trip, we can also deliver to you via Market Wagon.

We typically have everything on our current menu in stock at the shop, but if you want to guarantee that the pie will be available, we recommend placing our order by placing your order online.

We do not take special orders, but we do our best to provide a variety of great flavors in all of our monthly seasonal menus.

We rotate our menu monthly, which depends on a lot of factors including our access to local ingredients. For instance, we use local, in-season fruit as much as possible in the warmer months. If you are waiting for a specific pie to come back, you will likely see it around the same time of year it was last available.

Our pot pies come in two sizes. The 6" pot pie serves 1-2, and the 9" pot pie serves 4-6.

Our sweet pies are typically cut into 6 slices at the shop, but many of our customers do 8 slices at home. It all depends on the crowd you’re trying to feed!

In our shop, it's all about speed and convenience - without room for comfy chairs, we're all about grabbing what you need and heading out!

We can! We’ve provided many couples with special pies designed just for them and incorporating floral design from the wedding ceremony. Click here to read our write-up in Indianapolis Monthly. For all wedding-related inquiries, please email pielady@potsandpansindy.com.