Banana Cream Pie
Banana Cream Pie
Bananas, pastry cream, caramel, and chocolate. What’s not to love?? Made with our vegetarian pie crust.
Couldn't load pickup availability
how to store it
how to store it
This pie should be kept refrigerated at all times to maintain quality and food safety.
Shelf life: typically 3-5 days from purchase date.
animal products
animal products
dairy and eggs
allergens
allergens
wheat, egg, dairy, and soy

One of our favorite pies ever; the chocolate layer on the crust is fantastic touch. It is a slightly delicate pie - we weren't careful with the first one and it was a bit of a mess when we opened the box once we got home. However, we loved the flavor so much we bought another the following week. This time we were careful in transport and it was perfect when we got home. In fact, we are planning our next purchase before it leaves at the end of the month. LOL
We bought two of these pies for our daughter’s birthday get together last week. One of the pies was great! The other was so extremely soupy that when we would cut a piece it would collapse and spill into the container, making it impossible to serve pieces. It wouldn’t hold shape at all. Unfortunately that is the one we tried first and what our guests experienced. We love this place and some of our favorite pies are from here. But if that was our first experience with Pots and Pans we would likely never come back as that’s very disappointing for a $40 pie
Hi Thomas! Thanks for your feedback – your experience definitely wasn't the Pots & Pans quality you've seen in the past and I'm sorry you had a negative experience. I'd like to provide a credit for you for your next visit to help make it right. Please email hello@potsandpansindy.com with your order number and we'll get that taken care of for you. We appreciate your feedback!
-Ian M.
VERY runny. Closer to soup than custard. The flavor was good but a bit skimpy on the bananas. Served it in a bowl
Hi Wayne, so sorry you had that experience – that definitely is not up to our standards and I'd like to provide a credit for you for the next time you visit. Please email hello@potsandpansindy.com with your order number and we'll get that taken care of for you. We appreciate your feedback!
-Ian M.
Best pie ever!